In the last few years I have worked with many project, code and marketing platforms for teams and have yet to find the perfect app, so once again I have set-out to find something that will have solid adoption by creatives, management and marketing people. In my experaince if it’s not adopted 100% by the team it becomes useless and forcing mandatory use is never a great idea.
The adoption rate among users has everything to do with the UX, it should be intuitive within the first hour of use and the benefits should be obvious, the challenge is finding the right set of features.
For many years I did find an app setup that worked very well for technical teams using a mixture of Jira + HipChat + BeanStalk. But these type of revision/code/task platforms are really only good for technical teams, a.k.a programmers. The problem was that the marketing, project management, and creatives hated using Jira, it was overly complicated and the UI was confusing. The above mix is a solid setup and I continue to use Jira + Beanstalk for developers ( I have removed HipChat since I no longer work with remote developers), I needed something for everyone else.
I’n my search for the perfect tool I found there are a lot of apps which try to do to many things and suffer from not doing anything particularly well. A lot of project management apps include CRM’s, Wiki’s, client invoicing, advanced time and gantt charts, none of which I’m particularly interested in.
The two main criteria I actually care about,
- Easy to communicate ideas and tasks at the project level
- Due dates
My more detailed prerequisites are fairly simple,
- A very clean easy to use UI that works on multiple devices
- Projects with can be broken down into tasks and prioritized (drag and drop)
- Tasks must allow for attaching files/documents with previews and even better… inline editing and approval. Tasks should not be rigid or complex.
- Easy to group people per project level
- Project notes and files, tag support and a good search.
- Activity stream
Things I consider clutter
- Gantt or any bird’s eye view time tracking charts.
- Kanban, Agile or any other “boards” , I manage marketers/ products, not multi level applications. We don’t do “sprints”, we work on campaigns, content, sales and graphics.
- Timers, invoicing, workload analytics or any other stuff that should be handled by an accountant/controller.
- Revision control or code integration.
- Rigid task management – I only care about due dates
- Multiple template choices, complex workflows or custom approval systems.
I logged into all of these services to test them out.
Apps which made the cut
- Asana.com – Simple, easy, fast.
- Teamwork.com – A little more complex than Asana but good overall structure
- Wrike.com – Same as Teamwork.com more or less
- Proofhub.com – Really great to have a built in proofing system, not as great as the others with project management, but good enough.
- Azendoo.com – Simple nice UI that hits the mark, such as separate organizations, subjects, and tasks.
- Glip.com – Awesome interface, image annotation, nice management style. A +
- Getflow.com Clean UI with some cool features like segmented tasks, easy group task management.
- Trello.com – Great for almost anything, yet not super well suited for multiple marketing teams or static tasks.
These did not make the cut
- Basecamp.com – Out dated by a decade, horrible interface
- Brightpod.com – Solid interface but totally stupid that you cannot attach files to task easily WTF. Kanban project board is useless for our needs.
- Do.com – Cool idea but geared towards meetings
- Qiup.com – Also good idea but document centric.
- Podio.com – Overly complex, Asana just does it better. Would be ok if you really care about task completion and segmenting workloads based on a layered hierarchy but …meh.
- Samepage.io – Cool but lacks actual project or subject management that can contain multiple tasks (or pages in their case).
- 5pmweb.com – Very outdated UI and workflow in terms of attaching assets to tasks within project (it is possible but no fast).
- Paymoapp.com – Client and invoice focused..nope.
- Slack.com – Chat app that wastes everyone time.
- Any service that did not have a demo easily ready and required a sales person to setup.. seriously fire your sales lead.
The top finalists for me had the ability to attach files to tasks and annotate them within the task. SO much time is wasted via email with creatives when a simple annotation explains everything.
They also have very clean easy to use UI without clutter and got the basics of project management right.
# 1 Glip.com
Combines a killer interface and annotations
Annotations and even a approval system (nice), with a decent project management UI.
Killer management UI but no annotations for assets.
Honorable mention: Asana.com and Getflow.com
After the above evaluation, we started to use Glip but ran into a few problems we did not expect in terms of the UI showing us what we wanted, we are now testing Proofhub and it’s working better, even though the task management UI is not as intuitive as the others mentioned above.
I will update this post in a month to see which app actually worked. To give some context to exactly what I am managing it is the following: Brand and marketing oversight with approximately 20 social media accounts, 4 marketing managers, 2-3 freelance artists, 1 freelance programmer, 1-2 assistant marketers, 1 design agency, 4 ad agencies, and too many partners and assets to mention.
I am in no way affiliated or making an referral money off this, I just hope is saves someone time.